Hand Crafted Cakes Made Daily with Love

Closed Monday & Tuesday

Today's flavors:

SOLD OUT

Call us to order your
favorites!
614.754.8828

BAKED TODAY fresh
Classic Buckeye
classic-buckeye-home
Classic Buckeye

Chocolate cake with a sweet, creamy peanut butter center, topped with dark chocolate buttercream icing and a touch of sweet, creamy peanut butter.

Cookies & Cream
cookies-cream-home
Cookies & Cream

An Oreo baked inside a white cake, topped with Kittie’s vanilla bean buttercream and coated with crushed Oreo cookies.

Lemon Meringue
lemon-meringue-home
Lemon Meringue

Graham cracker crust baked at the bottom of our lemon cake, fresh lemon curd center, topped with Grandma Micky’s frosting – lightly toasted, of course.

PB & J
pb-j-home
PB & J

White cake with seedless red raspberry jelly center, topped with peanut butter buttercream icing and garnished with crushed peanuts.

S’more
smore-home
S’more

Chocolate graham cracker cake, topped with toasted marshmallow icing.

White Lavender
white-lavender-home
White Lavender

White Cake made with Ohio Lavender, topped with Kittie’s vanilla buttercream icing and garnished with a bud of Ohio lavender.

Coconut Whoopie Pie
coconut-cream-home
Coconut Whoopie Pie

Grandma Micky’s fluffy frosting sandwiched between two coconut “cake-like” cookies and garnished with shredded coconut.

Micky-O
mickey-o-home
Micky-O

Our version of an oatmeal cream pie – two oatmeal cookies filled with Grandma Micky’s fluffy frosting.

Cinnamon Roll
cinnamon roll image
Cinnamon Roll

The perfect traditional cinnamon roll—does it need any more description?

Cinnamon Scone
scone-cinnamon-home
Cinnamon Scone

Ultimate cinnamon lover’s breakfast – cinnamon scone with cinnamon filling, topped with a cinnamon glaze.

Biscuit & Jam
biscuit-jam-home
Biscuit & Jam

Buttermilk biscuit with homemade jam baked right in the center.

Brittle
brittle-home
Brittle

Our cookie bar brittle, the perfect sweet and salty treat – graham cracker crust with toffee, chocolate chips, almonds and sea salt packed in a 4-ounce bag.

Cold Brew Stubbie
cold-brew-stubbie-home
Cold Brew Stubbie

Stumptown Cold Brew is everything you know and love about Stumptown Coffee. The same formula brewed by hand in cafes for years is now bottled and ready to tuck into coolers on camping trips, park picnics, backyard BBQs and anytime in between.

Coffee
coffee-home
Coffee

Stumptown Coffee Roasters’ “Hair bender” is a complex blend featuring coffee from all three of the major growing regions; Latin America, East Africa and Indonesia. Purchase a cup to go, or a 12 oz. bag to take home. Brewed fresh daily.

DON’T SEE YOUR FAVORITE? We bake what’s most requested by our customers. You can call us at 614.754.8828 to request a flavor. We’ll post our daily menu the evening before right here, as well as on our Facebook and Instagram page.

See our full menu
Good Flavors,
Good Decisions

We believe good implies more than just good taste.

DON’T BAKE EXCESS AMOUNTS.
USE ONLY REAL INGREDIENTS.
INSPIRED BY FAMILY & COMMUNITY.

Read our story
we’re on instagram

@kittiescakes

Instagram image
Instagram image
Instagram image
Instagram image